In Brain Sciences, Nova Fellow Alan Logan, Scholar Susan Prescott, and coauthors explore how emerging gut microbiome science may reshape criminal justice approaches to understanding behavior and culpability.
Recent court decisions in the United States and Europe have dismissed driving while intoxicated charges based on auto-brewery syndrome. This condition occurs when gut microbes produce significant alcohol without consumption. Defendants were victims of involuntary intoxication. These cases open broader questions about how gut microbes influence behavior.
Research demonstrates that gut microorganisms communicate with the brain through multiple pathways. These include neural signaling, immune responses, and production of neuroactive chemicals. The authors introduce the concept of the “legalome.” This refers to applying gut microbiome and multi-omics sciences in forensic contexts.
Studies link gut microbial disturbances to conditions associated with higher justice involvement; these include ADHD, conduct disorder, and aggressive behavior. Fecal transplant experiments show that transferring microbiota from individuals with neuropsychiatric conditions can induce similar behavioral changes in recipients. While most research remains in early stages, the findings challenge traditional legal assumptions about free will and moral agency.





